The Consensus Trance
2,511 ViewsSeveral of you have expressed your thoughts about the cognitive dissonance you’re experiencing due to blogs like this one and the realization that something is seriously amiss. You’re not alone. From What a Way To Go:
When I am with those precious few who have grokked deeply the world situation - who have felt their way through the enormity, the complexity, the fear and the anger, the grief, the despair - when I am with those people, we find that “it” – call it the end of the world, the apocalypse, the collapse, the great turning, call it whatever you like – “it” is pretty much all we talk about. Of course it is. Once your switch gets flipped, once you know, then every single aspect of your life has to be readjusted to this new reality. Every nook and cranny of your psyche must be realigned. Every mundane detail. Every plan. Every expectation. Every assumption. Every hope. Every dream. On this side of that looking glass, the rules have all changed. And nothing remains the same.
Nothing.
I would not switch back, if such a thing were possible. The sense of sanity on this side of the mirror is worth every bit of the pain and upheaval it takes to get here. But because my whole world has tilted, I cannot walk easily in the world I once inhabited – what some have called “the consensus trance”. I try. But more and more often, I fail.
I like that term - “the consensus trance” aptly applies to the abiding indifference I’m seeing in the world.
There are, at least two “realities” that are now at the forefront of the collective consciousness. One remains stuck in the paradigm of the usual and ordinary. The other, is deeply alarmed by the signs of collapse occurring throughout the world. The former required adherence to the consensus that “all is well”, but you’d have to be in a trance to believe it. The other, eyes wide open, are daily beholding the shock and awe of a collapsing civilization due to ongoing human stupidity.
One reality requires almost nothing other then the daily grind for existence (you’ve got to do that anyway). The other reality requires a sharpened mind, honed and trained to carefully look at and examine the other reality, ultimately rejecting it.
This tears at all the known comfort zones and can be debilitating, destabilizing and even dangerous. But you cannot go back, it’s not really possible. This is a subject area that I have had long discussions about, in private. The ability to cope with the other reality (and it is very real to those that embrace it) becomes increasingly difficult. The connections you once had are significantly diminished, or even abolished altogether. This is the inevitable result of the absorption of evidence that changes perception from one reality to the other. The process causes cognitive dissonance, and the loss of stability.
Further examination though, reveals that even this concept was mistaken. Stability was an illusion, built up by an entire apparatus of lies and deceptions. This then, is discovered to be the root basis for that first reality, the one in which we were all born into. Stability is then discarded and eventually replaced with. . . nothing. Not instability, nor anything else. If anything, stability simply becomes existence.
In a sense, hope dies. But first, I need to clarify this. Hope is based upon promise, and promise is predicated upon stability. The steady-state or even improvement of things implied in stability is gone. So when stability is tossed out the window, along with all the other illusions, hope transforms into something else. It’s not really “dead” in the sense that there is no more hope, because that is simply untrue. Hope in the traditional view of stability is gone. Hope becomes something else.
In the new reality, traditional hope is soon realized to be for the hopeless. Hope is for those who do not take charge. Hope is for promise(s) based upon the steady-state of stability, which is to say, the status quo. Never changing, or changing little and always improving. Those that embrace hope in the status quo are truly the ones without any real hope. They’re the ongoing victims of circumstance.
Hope, for the new reality, becomes several things. Focus, dedication, determination, effort, intelligence and will power. Stability is no longer sought after as it once was, or even embraced. Flexibility becomes key instead. The new reality embraces change, recognizing that this is truly the way of the world. Hope becomes a new dynamic encompassing all of these things.
I have hope for the future, but it’s not the same definition of hope employed by many. It embraces change, even cataclysmic change, as the only “real hope” there is. This is the hope that holds the real promise. Stability is no longer a part of it.
The consensus trance denies all of this, because the steady-state of stability is threatened. Vast segments of the population absolutely refuse to correctly identify the changes that are occurring in our world. Their denial is hard to take, and even harder to witness as denial blunders ahead, destroying even more of the biosphere. Clearly, they have not made the journey from one reality to the other. The critical examination of thought, action, events and outcomes eludes them. Their world is illusion, and to them, very real.
Our world is just as real and just as tangible. But we’re badly outnumbered, and more often then not, always looking in to that other world and shaking our heads in disbelief. We are beset by loneliness, isolation, discouragement and even mutual distrust, because our reality doesn’t align with the dominant paradigms. But we already know, that doesn’t make us wrong. In fact, it demonstrates the rightness of our reality and even reinforces it.
In a sense, our reality requires the existence of the former reality we once knew. This is because of several things. First off, our reality is incomplete. It’s really a transitional reality. We have yet to become what we embrace. If we’re honest, we’ll admit it.
This transitional reality is still very much dependent upon the former reality in many, many ways. An example is how we still long for the connections and comforts of that world. This can be friends, family, entertainment and creature comforts. We are not as disconnected as we may like to think. Our dependency is still quite evident. And when that world collapses as I’ve long discussed, that dependency and shock will affect us deeply. Our transitional reality is then, inadequate an incomplete.
To put this into perspective, imagine an aboriginal tribe living in the Amazon. They’ve little or no contact with the outside world. When this world collapses, “our” reality, it won’t affect their reality and even their feelings very much, or at all. The only thing that will affect them is when their reality collapses. Perhaps the Amazon will dry up or something like that. But because they do not have one foot in this world, and one foot in our world, they will be largely unaffected. The collapse of civilization will benefit them immensely, while it would damage us far, far more.
Back to our transitional reality - because this reality is straddling the fence between two worlds, we will be affected very much by the collapse of our civilization. However, we will also be far better prepared then our fellow world travelers who embrace the first, traditional reality of the world. We’re preparing for destabilization, they’re not. We’re preparing for food shortages and riots, they’re not. We’re preparing for job loss, economic meltdown and bread lines, they’re not.
Their world is intricately linked and interdependent upon everything working together, in relative harmony. This works, as long as the resources last and as long as some such catastrophe doesn’t come their way. But when disaster or collapse hits, their reality will suffer horrific blows. Even our transitional reality will endure far better, we saw it coming and we prepared for it.
Transitional reality then, is better equipped because it no longer embraces the steady state equilibrium of society. But I stress that other point I brought forth - this too will prove to be inadequate in the end. I think it is only important to recognize this, because there is almost nothing that can be done about it at this time. Transitional reality will prepare you for whatever is coming and by it’s very nature, allow you to be flexible enough to embrace what we cannot see yet. To me, this is sufficient and all I can expect.
As the collapse deepens, the transitional reality will become the new dominant reality and will be embraced by expanding numbers. I take little comfort in this fact, because I believe it will be too few, too late. A ill-timed belief is simply not much good to anyone, even you. It’s important to be flexible as the world dynamics change. Just don’t do it too late or it won’t do you any good.









May 11th, 2007 at 4:31 pm
one of your better recent rants kemosabi
On the topic of “Hope”, here’s the link to
http://survivalacres.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=824&highlight=hope+kills
“You must be the change you wish to see” ~ Mahatma Gandi
May 11th, 2007 at 6:33 pm
Thank you! I’ve tried so many times to express this. Hell, we all have. Awesome.
May 11th, 2007 at 7:51 pm
Alas, whether we wish it or not, the old world has to end when the resources run dry. (I guess I’m what you might call a reluctant “crash observer”.) I find myself wanting to raise the alarm and do whatever I can to make those stuck in the “consensus trance” aware. Perhaps, I sometimes think to myself, if we all started right now we could work together and build a new world with a sustainable future.
But that’s not going to happen. I think of the people I see like investors who have made a very bad decision. They are gambling that somebody else is going to look out for them. Bizarrely, many will perish without even understanding the reason! Are we wrong, therefore, to concentrate primarily on our own personal survival—and let nature take its course? The implications of collapse and die-off will overwhelm all of us—even those firmly in the “transitional reality” of the new paradigm.
May 12th, 2007 at 8:23 am
A very good read. You have put in to words what I feel. Thankyou.
May 12th, 2007 at 5:52 pm
I’ve decided that the subject of this post is why this site isn’t as popular as it deserves. Someone described this site as “hard-core” and that is very true, but its not spot-on. I think this site is one of the few places where people “get it”. You could probably make this site way more popular if you gave a watered down version of what you believe, but I wouldn’t read you writings if you did. You just don’t kiss enough ass, and don’t leave much wiggle and squirm room for those who you make uncomfortable with being honest. A lot of your posts leave you with that gut-punch kind of feel, where you are gasping for breath and angry. Not angry with you, but with the stupidity that has and does lead to the post topic.
You are probably one of the best collapse documenting writers out there today. But we all know honesty doesn’t have a huge following in today’s world. Please keep up the excellent work and sacrifice that you make to help the rest of us.
May 13th, 2007 at 8:58 am
Wow! I think that’s the highest compliment I’ve ever received, thank you!
I didn’t do it alone, not by any means. I’ve had the benefit of working with several others, including lonewolf, who is deserving of recognition (as crusty as he may be). Others have helped with their own writings and insights and have taught me a lot.
I’ve long believed that this blog has seriously hurt my online business efforts, for the same reasons you stated. It’s too much. The seriousness of the situation creates severe conflicts with the present paradigm. Rejection and denial is easier then to soberly face the hard reality of what our civilization has done and what it’s future will now be.
Most people seem to be cognitively aware at some subliminal level of our predicament, but seemingly unable to break free from the steady-state of denial and frozen indifference. I take this to mean that they’re already dead.
May 14th, 2007 at 11:52 am
An underlying suicidal sentiment underlies much of modern civilization. It is crushing and frenetic, obsessive and depressive, alienating and repressive, sucking the very marrow right out of life. Yet like a lifelong prisoner, people simply cannot see any other existence, and simply “tune out” realities that conflict with their existing world view. A self defense mechanism.
Many will ‘embrace the suck’, when it comes.
May 15th, 2007 at 12:11 pm
[…] I find this very frustrating. But frankly, I believe it to be true despite that fact. Humanity is quite willing to gamble it all on the secret hope that the outcome won’t be quite that bad as now being warned around the world. This is the false hope for the hopeless, the consensus trance that deceives and misleads the “faithful” who believe that “staying the course” will somehow mystically and magically change the outcome. […]
July 6th, 2007 at 12:42 am
[…] Convince yourself. That’s your job, not mine. “Only by doing this does the ‘investigator’ come to the truth as they see it”. Don’t let the consensus trance destroy you. A transitional reality is the very best you can do right now. […]
July 31st, 2007 at 7:59 am
Thomas Berry in The Dream of the Earth describes the entire industrial age as a “period of technological entrancement, an altered state of consciousness, a mental fixation that alone can explain how we came to ruin our air and water and soil and to severely damage all our basic life systems.”
He goes on to state: “During this period the human mind has been placed within the narrowest confines it has experienced since consciousness emerged from its Paleolithic phase. Even the most primitive tribes have a larger vision of the universe, of our place and functioning within it, a vision that extends to celestial regions of space and to interior depths of the human in a manner far exceeding the parameters of our world of technological confinement.”
Thanks for your blog…a straight-forward assessment of humans.
Also, a wonderful analysis on what to do for the Transition and how to keep one’s Third Eye (and Heart) open.
August 14th, 2007 at 11:48 pm
[…] If your paradigm is failing, or if you have made that step to a transitional reality, then you’ve already come much farther then most. Your judgment will be based on an entirely different set of self-interests then those who have not made that journey. And this is a critical point - the self-interest that will see you through collapse will be unlike anything you’ve probably ever known. You will finally be faced with the physical reality and demands of your own existence. […]
October 2nd, 2007 at 8:03 pm
‘The Consensus Trance’ - I love how that expression hits the nail on the head. The use of Robert Heinlein’s ‘grokking’ instantly endears the writer to me also.